
Postcard Cabins Eastern Catskills
Best for couples or solo travelers who want private cabins, outdoor evenings by a fire pit, and easy access to hiking and waterfalls.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Postcard Cabins Eastern Catskills is a small, design-forward cabin outpost for people who want private, nature-focused stays near Kaaterskill Falls. Comfort Inn Saugerties is a budget-friendly, nationally branded hotel in Saugerties for travelers who want predictable amenities like free breakfast and an indoor pool.
Updated · about 23 km apart (≈14 mi)

Best for couples or solo travelers who want private cabins, outdoor evenings by a fire pit, and easy access to hiking and waterfalls.

Best for price-conscious travelers who prefer a familiar chain hotel with an indoor pool, free buffet breakfast and a staffed front desk.
When Postcard Cabins Eastern Catskills wins: pick Postcard if you want a quiet, self-guided cabin stay with a private outdoor space (firepit, grill, Adirondack chairs) and close access to Kaaterskill Falls and Catskill hiking.
When Comfort Inn Saugerties wins: pick Comfort Inn if you want a conventional hotel with an indoor pool, daily complimentary buffet breakfast, 24-hour front desk service, and easier town access without needing a car for basic conveniences.
Bottom line: Postcard Cabins is a small-scale, outdoors-first cabin outpost for people prioritizing privacy and nature; Comfort Inn Saugerties is the more conventional, budget-friendly hotel choice with standard amenities and more on-site services.
| Category | Postcard Cabins Eastern Catskills | Comfort Inn Saugerties |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Private, quiet cabin outpost focused on outdoor time | Branded, budget hotel with basic guest services |
| Location | Rural Catskill woodland near Kaaterskill Falls (282 Cairo Junction Rd, Catskill, NY) | Town-edge hotel on Route 32 in Saugerties (2790 Route 32, Saugerties, NY) |
| Size / rooms | About 51–56 tiny cabins across ~60–85 acres; room types: Cabin, 2 Queen Beds; Cabin, 1 Queen Bed; Suite | 65 air-conditioned rooms; many standard room type names (e.g., Room, 1 King Bed, Non Smoking; 2 Queen Beds, Nonsmoking) |
| Guests & age policy | All-ages property; minimum age to check in 18 | |
| Pool | No pool on-site | Indoor pool (hours noted: pool access 7 AM–10 PM) |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar; cabins have kitchenettes and guests are encouraged to bring/prepare food | No signature on-site restaurant listed in supplier data; complimentary buffet breakfast served daily |
| Spa / fitness | No spa or fitness center | Not published |
| Known for | Private outdoor firepits, kitchenette-equipped cabins, proximity to Kaaterskill Falls and hiking | Budget-friendly chain comforts, free breakfast, indoor pool and predictable services |
| Check-in / front desk | Contactless, self-guided check-in (assignment and entry code sent by text morning of arrival); check-in begins 4:00 PM | 24-hour front desk; check-in begins 2:00 PM |
| Pet policy | Dogs allowed (non-refundable $50 fee per stay, max two dogs; service animals free) | Pets allowed (pet fee: USD 30 per pet, per night; service animals exempt) |
Postcard Cabins sits in private woodland near Kaaterskill Falls and North-South Lake.
Choose Postcard if you want to be based in the woods with direct access to Catskills hiking and waterfalls.
Comfort Inn sits on Route 32 in Saugerties, near town services and local sights.
Choose Comfort Inn if you want easy access to Saugerties town, restaurants and more town-based services.
Postcard offers small private cabins with kitchenettes and outdoor spaces.
If you want your own small kitchen and private outdoor living area, Postcard is a clear fit.
Comfort Inn provides standard, air-conditioned hotel rooms with refrigerators in-room.
Choose Comfort Inn if you prefer a conventional hotel room with standard in-room conveniences.
Postcard has no on-site restaurants; guests cook at cabins or drive to nearby eateries.
Bring groceries or plan to drive to town for meals—Postcard is not a full-service dining property.
Comfort Inn offers a complimentary daily buffet breakfast; no signature on-site restaurant listed in supplier data.
Comfort Inn covers morning meals for guests; other meals require town options or takeout.
Postcard intentionally does not offer a pool; the stay centers on outdoor cabin experiences.
No pool at Postcard—expect natural swimming spots a short drive away rather than on-site water amenities.
Comfort Inn lists an indoor pool among its guest amenities.
Comfort Inn provides an indoor pool and predictable hotel amenities that Postcard does not.
Postcard's offer is quiet outdoor time and hiking rather than on-site wellness or nightlife.
Pick Postcard for peaceful nights under the trees rather than wellness facilities or nightlife.
Comfort Inn provides easier access to town nightlife and basic wellness conveniences through town businesses.
Comfort Inn is better if you want to be close to town dining and nightlife or need front-desk assistance in the evening.

Private cabins with individual firepits, grills and secluded outdoor seating.

Branded hotel amenities like free breakfast, an indoor pool and a 24-hour front desk.

Closer driving distance to Kaaterskill Falls and North-South Lake trailheads.

Multiple standard room types, fridges in rooms and an indoor pool for all-ages comfort.
Postcard Cabins Eastern Catskills is much closer—about a 2.5-mile drive to Kaaterskill Falls; Comfort Inn is farther away.
Comfort Inn offers a complimentary buffet breakfast but no signature on-site restaurant is listed; Postcard Cabins has no restaurant and guests are expected to prepare food in cabin kitchenettes or drive to nearby towns.
Yes. Postcard allows dogs with a non-refundable $50 per-stay fee (max two dogs); Comfort Inn accepts pets with a pet fee of USD 30 per pet, per night (service animals exempt).
Comfort Inn is better if you want a staffed front desk, daily housekeeping-style services and an indoor pool; Postcard is self-guided with limited on-site services.
Explore how Postcard Cabins Eastern Catskills stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·